The Appointment Firm ← All articles

Home · Blog · Candidate care

Candidate care

Counter-offers, and what to do before one lands

You have heard that eighty per cent of people who accept a counter-offer leave within six months. We went looking for the study behind it. There is not one, and a recruiter repeating unverifiable numbers to a candidate is in a weak position the moment they are asked where it came from.

Every recruiter has said it, most have believed it, and it appears in roughly half the counter-offer articles online: eighty per cent of candidates who accept a counter-offer leave within six months. Some versions say ninety per cent within a year.

We tried to find the source. The trail runs to a handful of citations of the Wall Street Journal that lead to no locatable article, and to a body called the National Employment Association that does not appear to exist.1 Beyond that it is agencies citing other agencies, in a loop with no origin.

Why this matters more than it seems

Not because the underlying claim is necessarily false. It may well be directionally right. It matters because of who is saying it and why.

A recruiter has an obvious commercial interest in a candidate declining a counter-offer. When that recruiter produces a dramatic statistic with no source, and the candidate later discovers it cannot be verified, the damage is not to the statistic. It is to everything else the recruiter said.

You do not need a number to make this argument. You need the reason the person was on the market in the first place.

The argument that survives scrutiny

Ask why someone is looking and the honest answer is rarely only money. It is a manager, a ceiling, a promise made two years ago and not kept, work that stopped being interesting. A counter-offer is a response to the resignation, not to any of that.

So the question to put to a candidate is not "did you know most people who accept these leave anyway". It is simpler, and it does not require a citation:

What were you unhappy about, and does this offer change it?

If the honest answer is yes, then accepting is the right decision and no statistic should talk them out of it. If the answer is no, they will hear that themselves as they say it, which is considerably more persuasive than hearing it from you.

The second question, which most people skip

Why did it take a resignation to produce this money?

Either the employer knew they were underpaid and waited to be forced, or they did not know, which says something about how closely anyone was paying attention. Neither answer is fatal. Both are worth the candidate thinking about before they accept.

Doing the work earlier

The counter-offer conversation is largely decided before it happens. By the time an employer is in a room with a resignation letter, they have the advantages of relationship, familiarity and immediacy, and you have a phone call.

Before the resignation goes in

  • ✓Ask what a counter-offer would look like. Most candidates can predict the number. Predicting it out loud takes most of its power away.
  • ✓Establish what they are actually leaving. Written down, in their words, early enough that it is not a rationalisation.
  • ✓Make sure the new offer has a story, not only a figure, so there is something to weigh against loyalty and habit.
  • ✓Stay present through notice. This is when the current employer is most attentive and the new one usually is not.
On statistics generally. There are widely circulated figures for counter-offer acceptance and subsequent attrition, and some may be sound. We have not cited them because we could not trace them to a study we could read. If you find one, it is worth more than the folklore.

Sources

  1. Ken Davies, So do 80% of people who accept counteroffers really leave within 12 months? — an attempt to trace the original source, which finds no locatable study and no trace of the body usually credited with it.
AF

The Appointment Firm

We have been placing people for 22 years from Northcliff, Johannesburg, across finance, IT and engineering. These notes come from our own desk, and so does the software we built to run it.

See the resignation coming

Notes, motivations and client feedback in one place, so the conversation that prevents a counter-offer happens on time.

Book a demo