The Appointment Firm ← All articles

Home · Blog · Clients

Clients

Telling a client the role is not fillable

Every desk has taken a role it knew was undeliverable and worked it anyway. The fee was theoretical, the client relationship was real, and both were damaged by the same thing: nobody said so in week one.

There is a role on your desk right now that cannot be filled at that salary, in that location, with those requirements. Everyone half-knows it. Nobody has said it.

The reason is not cowardice. It is that saying so costs something immediate and certain, while working the role costs something delayed and deniable.

What silence actually costs

Four weeks of sourcing against an impossible brief. Candidates approached about a role that will not close, some of whom you will want to call again about something real. A client whose confidence erodes with each shortlist, and who concludes that the market is short or that you are.

And at the end of it, the same conversation you avoided in week one, held from a much weaker position: now it sounds like an excuse rather than expertise.

In week one it is a professional judgement. In week six it is an excuse. The content is identical.

How to know early

The signals are usually available before you start.

Any one is manageable. Three together is a role that will consume a month and close nothing.

Saying it well

The difference between a difficult conversation that strengthens a relationship and one that ends it is almost entirely in the preparation.

The shape of the conversation

  • ✓Lead with evidence, not opinion. Three comparable placements and what they paid beats "the market is difficult".
  • ✓Be specific about the blocker. Not "it is a tough brief" but "these two requirements together describe about nine people in Gauteng".
  • ✓Bring options, not a refusal. Raise the band, split the role, drop one requirement, or accept a longer runway.
  • ✓Say what you will do either way. Willingness to work a hard role once the client has chosen with open eyes is very different from silent compliance.
  • ✓Put it in writing afterwards. Not defensively. So the decision is a shared record rather than a memory.

Why no system will do this for you

Software can tell you the salary is below your last five placements. It cannot judge whether this particular client, on this particular Tuesday, needs the data or the reassurance first. It cannot hear that the band is fixed because someone above them fixed it, which changes the conversation entirely.

Bring the evidence with you, by all means. But the person who tells a client something they do not want to hear, and keeps the relationship, is doing the part of this job that has no substitute.

AF

The Appointment Firm

We have been placing people for 22 years from Northcliff, Johannesburg, across finance, IT and engineering. These notes come from our own desk, and so does the software we built to run it.

Evidence for the difficult conversation

Placement history and feedback in one place, so the market view is a record rather than an opinion.

Book a demo