The Appointment Firm ← All articles

Home · Blog · Clients

Clients

Why the second-best candidate is often the right hire

A shortlist puts candidates in order against a document. Nobody works for a document. The gap between those two facts is where a recruiter earns their fee, and it is the gap no scoring system can close.

Rank three candidates against a specification and the order is usually clear. Ask which of the three will still be there in two years, doing the job well, and the order frequently reverses.

What ranking cannot weigh

A score measures fit against requirements as written. It has nothing to say about the things that decide whether a hire works.

Trajectory. The strongest candidate on paper is sometimes at the end of their interest in the work. The second is halfway up and accelerating. Both look identical in a competency match; only one is still improving in eighteen months.

The manager. A candidate who needs structure, placed under a manager who provides none, fails regardless of ability. This is knowable in advance, and only by someone who has met both.

What the team is missing. Teams do not need the best individual. They need the person who supplies what is absent, which is frequently not more of what they already have.

Why they want it. The candidate who wants this specific role beats the one who wants a role, every time, and it is invisible on a CV.

The best candidate is the one who fits the brief. The right candidate is the one who is still there, doing it well, in two years. They are often not the same person.

The evidence for humility about credentials

The selection research is blunt about how weakly the usual proxies predict performance. Years of experience correlates with later job performance at roughly 0.18, adding almost nothing beyond general ability, and most of the learning happens in the first couple of years. Educational credentials fare little better within a given applicant pool.1

Structured interviews and general mental ability sit at the top of the same table.1 Which means the two things most likely to put someone at the head of an automated ranking, experience and credentials, are among the weaker predictors available.

Making the argument to a client

Recommending the second name on your own list requires you to explain why, which is a good discipline.

How to put it

  • ✓Concede the ranking. Say plainly that the other candidate matches the specification more closely.
  • ✓Name the requirement you are trading. Two years less experience, a different sector.
  • ✓Name what you are buying with it. Motivation, trajectory, a gap in the team that this person fills.
  • ✓Give the evidence, from the conversation, not an impression.
  • ✓Let them choose. Presenting both, with reasons, is the job. Deciding for them is not.

Do that a few times and something changes in the relationship. You stop being the supplier of the list and become the person who reads it. That is a considerably harder role to replace with software.

Sources

  1. Schmidt, F. & Hunter, J. (1998), The Validity and Utility of Selection Methods in Personnel Psychology — summary (PDF); validity hierarchy discussed at Plum
AF

The Appointment Firm

We have been placing people for 22 years from Northcliff, Johannesburg, across finance, IT and engineering. These notes come from our own desk, and so does the software we built to run it.

Rank on the brief, decide on the person

Match scoring against requirements, plus the internal fit notes that never appear on the client's copy.

Book a demo