The Appointment Firm ← All articles

Home · Blog · Briefs & sourcing

Briefs & sourcing

What a good job brief actually contains

Most briefs describe a job that does not exist: a wish list assembled by committee. The ones that get filled quickly answer three questions the specification never asks, and take about twenty minutes longer to write.

Every recruiter has taken a brief that felt complete and turned out to be useless. Ten bullet points of requirements, a salary band, a start date. You source against it, send four strong people, and every one comes back rejected for a reason that appeared nowhere in the document.

The problem is rarely that the client was vague. It is that the brief captured what the job looks like rather than what it is. Those are different documents, and only one of them helps you find a person.

The three questions a specification never asks

1. Why is this role open?

A replacement hire and a growth hire are not the same job, even with identical specifications. If someone left, you need to know what they found difficult, because your candidate will find it difficult too. If the role is new, nobody in the business has done it yet, which means the requirements are a guess and the first six months will be negotiated rather than delivered.

Ask it plainly, and listen to the pause before the answer.

2. Who has done this well here before?

Culture is difficult to describe in the abstract and easy to describe through a person. Ask a hiring manager to name someone who thrived in a similar seat and explain why, and you will learn more in two minutes than a values page will teach you in an hour. You will also hear the qualities that are never written down: tolerance for ambiguity, willingness to push back, comfort with a founder who changes direction on a Friday.

3. What does the first six months look like?

Not the job description. The actual work. What lands on the desk in week one, what has to be true by month three, what would make everyone agree at month six that the hire was right. If the client cannot answer this, the role is not ready to go to market, and telling them so is worth more than a shortlist.

A brief that cannot describe success at six months is not a brief. It is a hope with a salary band attached.

What to write down

Once you have those answers, the document almost writes itself. The parts that matter are rarely the parts a template asks for.

The parts worth capturing

  • ✓The real must-haves. Usually three, not eleven. Everything else is a preference, and preferences are what you trade when a strong candidate is imperfect.
  • ✓The deal-breakers. The things that will sink an otherwise perfect person. Notice period, location, a specific system, a certification.
  • ✓Who decides. Names, not job titles, and what each person is actually assessing.
  • ✓The process, with dates. How many stages, who is on leave, and when a decision realistically gets made.
  • ✓What the role is not. The single most useful line in any brief, and the one nobody writes.

The brief is an agreement, not a form

The reason a good brief speeds everything up is not that it improves your search terms. It is that it forces a conversation the client has been avoiding, usually with themselves. Two stakeholders discover they wanted different things. A must-have turns out to be negotiable. A salary band meets the market and loses.

Better to have that argument in the briefing call than after your third rejected shortlist. And when it happens in front of you, you stop being a supplier of CVs and start being the person who told them the truth early.

That is the whole trick. A brief is not a description of a job. It is a record of what everyone agreed the job is, at a moment when they were all in the same room.

AF

The Appointment Firm

We have been placing people for 22 years from Northcliff, Johannesburg, across finance, IT and engineering. These notes come from our own desk, and so does the software we built to run it.